Ferdinand Malcher

5 useful NgRx effects that don't rely on actions


In this article we will discuss how we can leverage the power of Effects in NgRx. We will use observable streams other than the usual action stream to build some powerful and neat effects.

Effects, effects, effects

When working with the ngrx/store library you might be familiar with the concept of Effects. Effects provide a powerful model to keep our reducers pure and describe side effect handling in a declarative way using RxJS streams.

If you're not familiar with ngrx/store or effects, please read about the core concepts and building blocks here.

Simply speaking, an effect is an Observable that maps its items to actions that will then be dispatched to the store automatically. In most cases, the source of an Effect is the global stream of actions:

myEffect$ = this.actions$.pipe(
  // do awesome things like fetching books from an API
  map(books => LoadBooksSuccess(books))

constructor(private actions$: Actions) {}

This effect takes the stream of all our actions and filters it by specific actions of the type LoadBooks. For each LoadBooks action it then performs some awesome stuff, e.g. retrieving the book list from the server. Finally, it converts the book list into a new action LoadBooksSuccess. The @Effect() decorator makes sure that the new action is being dispatched automatically.

While we usually take the actions stream as the source for our effects, it is not actually bound to this source. In fact you can take whatever Observable you want and take its values as your effect source.

The example data: Books

In the following examples we will use a book list as our data. The state tree looks like this:

interface BooksState {
  books: Book[];

We have a LoadBooks action that triggers an HTTP request through an effect:

loadBooks = this.actions$.pipe(
  mergeMap(() => this.service.getBooks().pipe( // get book list from service
    map(books => new LoadBooksSuccess(books)) // trigger action that saves new books to the store

The LoadBooksSuccess action invokes a reducer to add the book list to the state:

// ...
case BooksActionTypes.LoadBooksSuccess: {
  const books = action.payload;
  return { ...state, books };

Now that you know the setup, let's go through some use cases where it comes in handy to take some other Observables as source for our effects.

1.) Native events

Imagine you want to trigger an action whenever the user resizes the browser window. We're talking about a native event here that's not bound to a specific DOM node in our view. Using the fromEvent function from RxJS we can easily build up an observable stream of window resizing events. The debounce is just cosmetic and makes the stream only emit once when the user has stopped resizing for a certain amount of time. With the final resize event we can then dispatch a new action to our store:

import { fromEvent } from 'rxjs';
// ...

resize$ = fromEvent(window, 'resize').pipe(
  map(e => new MyWindowResizeAction(e))

This solution is very nice and clean, compared to subscribing to the event and then dispatching actions from one of our components.

2.) Timers/Intervals

We can follow a similar approach when it comes to intervals using the interval function. A specific use case could be a polling scenario where you want to dispatch an action every n seconds. Look at how slick we can go for this with an effect:

import { interval } from 'rxjs';
// ...

interval$ = interval(2000).pipe(
  map(_ => new MyFancyAction())

3.) Route events

Angular itself uses Observables extensively, e.g. in the router or for reactive forms. Of course, we can also use those streams in our effects. Let's say we want to fetch some data from the server when a specific route is being activated.

There are a few approaches to this:

  1. Dispatching the action from the routed component using this.store.dispatch(), usually within ngOnInit()
  2. Using a route guard to intercept the routing process and dispatch the action (as described in an article by Todd Motto here)
  3. Listen to router events in an effect

Number #3 is as simple as our previous examples: We can use the events Observable from the Angular Router class and listen to some specific routing events. With the event payload we can decide what to do next, for example dispatching a LoadBooks action:

loadBooks$ = this.router.events.pipe(
  filter(e => e instanceof ActivationStart)),
  filter(e => isRoute('books/list'))
  map(_ => new LoadBooks())

constructor(private router: Router) {}

// ...
function isRoute(path: string, event: ActivationStart) {
  const currentPath: string[] = [];
  let route = event.snapshot;

  while (route.parent) {
    if (route.routeConfig && route.routeConfig.path) {
    route = route.parent;
  return path === currentPath.reverse().join('/');

The event payload object is quite complex and we don't need to pick it to pieces here. What we did is to build the isRoute function to traverse through the router tree and bring all our route segments together.

Actually, this idea is pretty much the same like amcdnl followed with his ngrx-router library. Your effects become very simple and clean like this one:

import { ofRoute } from 'ngrx-router';
// ...

loadBooks$ = this.actions$.pipe(
  map(_ => new LoadBooks())

Using ngrx-router you can also match multiple routes, use route param placeholders or match by regular expressions. If you like the approach above you might want to check this one out!

4.) Fill the store implicitly

Exploring this a bit further we can do some advanced implicit magic: Retrieving data from somewhere whenever they are not present in the store. This is quite convenient when it comes to data we need all the time like configuration objects or generic lists of helping entities.

The key behind this idea is that store selectors like store.pipe(select(mySelector)) also return Observables. Thus, we can build an effect like the one following. Just read the code carefully first and then continue with the explanation below:

getBooks$ = this.store$.pipe(
  select(getAllBooks), // get book list from store
  filter(booksFromStore => booksFromStore.length == 0), // only continue if there are no books
  map(_ => new LoadBooks())

// Selector
const getAllBooks = createSelector(getBooksState, state => state.books);

This effect starts working when the book list in our store changes. Using the filter operator it continues the pipeline only when there are no books in the store. This can be the case when

  • the application starts with an empty initial state
  • or when the books have been deleted by some user action.

We then dispatch a LoadBooks action to load books from the server. So, whenever the books list happens to be empty, our store will automatically call the service and push the new books to the store.

⚠️ Please be careful when using this as it might introduce an anti-pattern. As Mike Ryan stated in a tweet, using store selectors as effects source "breaks a pattern and should probably be avoided".

5.) Loop of Death ☠️

Last but not least will be one of my favorites. What looks like a harmless little line of code is one of the most evil effects:

loopOfDeath$ = this.actions$;

It just takes all actions and replicates them into an infinite loop. Yay! Please… don't do this.


You can see that effects can go far beyond reacting to actions. Since effects basically are nothing more than observables that map to actions, we can use every observable as the source for our effects. However, please be careful not to mix up things and do not overuse this pattern! The majority of your effects should still follow the usual pattern described at the very top.

In some cases this one will come in handy, though. Have you experienced some cases other than the ones described here? Please write us an e-mail or ping us on Twitter – we're happy to discuss them!

Header image: Island In The Sky, Canyonlands National Park, Utah, 2018

Zurück | Back
Suggestions? Feedback? Bugs? Please fork/edit this page on Github.